|
"Israeli snipers are
in Iraq killing USGIs." Google
"Israeli Sniper" and that is one of the more often repeated items. A
favorite variation is that of the Female Israeli Sniper Instructors
deployed in Iraq to kill American Marines. You will not believe what you
will find on the Web. Drivel, propaganda, nonsense, call it what you will.
The fact is that words,
photographs and videos are among today's most fearsome, effective and
devastating weapons of war. Truth has little relevance to the cadre of
illegitimate, individuals-in-media's clothing, wielding their laptops,
cameras and digital video recorders, especially when a single photo or
depiction of an event can change the entire course of a conflict. One needs
look no further for an example than the partially staged and grossly
misreported July 30th 2006 Qana air-strike in southern Lebanon. It brought
Israel’s offensive to a standstill. Today the Media and Quasi Media are all
powerful. Chiefs-of-Staff are trumped by Editors-in-Chief.
I am both a laptop and
camera-carrying member of the Media and a sniper rifle carrying member of
the Israeli Police Civil Guard. I can assure you that the potential of the
damage I can inflict upon an enemy with a click of a shutter is 10,000 times
greater than with a squeeze of a trigger. I know of what I speak from
personal experience in Bosnia and the West Bank.
Unfortunately this
lesson is one the Israeli military and retinue of government spokespersons
have yet to learn. "Like a voice crying in the wilderness," I have been
preaching my message. And all the while Israel continues to fail to not only
capitalize on "media opportunities" that present themselves, but also to
prepare in a serious manner for the next all-out battle in the Media War.
The battle could
commence any moment. It is too critical to be left to the Communications
Advisors, Spokespersons and Spin Doctors to wage, or to not wage, as was the
case with the recent Lebanon War II. Here is what I would advise the
Advisors who are too busy spinning to listen.
First, stop antagonizing
the Foreign Press. Treat them as you would a valued resource, like one's
"Clientele," rather than as the enemy. Invest in Dale Carnegie How to
Make Friends and Influence People courses for the Prime Minister's
Office spokespersons, the staffs of Government Press and IDF Spokeswoman's
Offices and for the majority of government ministry spokespersons whose job
it is to "handle" the Foreign Press. Re-educate these individuals to
understand it is better to assist than "thwart."
Second, let the Press do
their job and cover the story as they like. The example of how the newly
declared Government of Croatia related to the Foreign Press provides a model
to be emulated. In a war for the fledgling country's very existence, the
Croatian leaders' belief was that allowing the Press maximum freedom to see,
experience and investigate would overall result in the truth being reported.
And the truth was on the side of the Croatians.
Under the patronage of
the President and Minister of Defense, the Croatian Foreign Press Bureau
(the "FPB") was established. The FPB was staffed with native born, foreign
educated, multilingual, articulate, young, Croatian men and women who
returned to their homeland to help in its struggle for independence "from
the Communists." FPB Headquarters was in the basement, the most safe
and secure area of the sandbagged from street-level to second story,
Zagreb Intercontinental Hotel. Members of the Foreign Press would present
their credentials to the Headquarters staff and immediately be issued a
Press Card. Then they were asked, in their native language, where they
wanted to go and what they wanted to see. They were provided with advice on
how best to accomplish their goal. But that is not all.
Foreign Press were
offered an FPB staffer who spoke their language to serve as a volunteer
guide, translator, intermediary and relief driver. Such staffers were to
take their charges everywhere they wanted to go. The staffers' duties
ended when, in the staffers' opinion, it became to dangerous for them to
continue with their charges, who having been warned their lives were now
seriously at risk, nonetheless decided to continue. Foreign Press were
unrestricted other than being advised not to interfere with or report
active, on-going Croatian military movements. If a member of the Croatian
military, or any one else for that matter, interfered with a reporter or the
reporter's ability to "get the story," the staffer would immediately notify
FPB Headquarters. The "Interferer" would receive immediate and convincing
instructions from a significant superior to stop interfering and start
assisting. History records that it was the Foreign Press that really
delivered and secured Croatian (and Bosnian) independence.
Certainly today the
Media's communications capabilities are light-years beyond those available
in the early '90s to reporters covering the battlefields of Croatia and
Bosnia-Herzegovina. The means to report live from “the Front” exist. Deal
with it as a challenge to be met with creative thinking rather than the
cop-out of prohibiting the presence of reporters on the battlefield.
Third, Israel's military
and police must assist in setting the truth free. Every Special Operations
Unit, every Border Police and IDF Company, should have combat photographers/videographers.
The images that these camerapersons record will be priceless. These must be
extraordinary individuals, possessing the same skill set as snipers, ghosts
of the battlefield, using a camera with the same patience, stealth and
cunning eye that a sniper uses a rifle. The sniper’s motto “One Shot, One
Kill,” must become the their credo. Paramount, they need the eye and
intuition to know, “that is The Shot.”
Providing IDF Units with
camcorders is a “been there, done that” abject failure. Recently the IDF
Spokeswoman established a “Combat Film and Photography Unit” to train
soldiers in infantry and armored platoons to document operations. At least
the need for visual resources is partially acknowledged. Unfortunately the
Spokeswoman’s game plan evinces defensive thinking when nothing less than a
full-court press offensive is needed.
Acknowledge that knowing
what to shoot is as important as being technically able to make the shot.
The teenage Israeli conscripts sent from their units to the Spokeswoman’s
Combat Photographer’s course will learn technical skills, but I doubt will
have the background or instinct to know what image will win the hearts and
minds of middle Americans or Europeans. Possessing that ability is quite a
bit to expect from even the seasoned, 20 year-old photographers on the
Spokeswoman’s staff.
Madam General, use
mature, experienced photojournalists instead. Take my word for it, they are
here and ready to take-on the assignment in the context of reserve duty.
Lastly, start
identifying “Visual Opportunities” and exploit rather than waste them. One
recent example is enough to make my point. The IDF Spokeswoman Announcement
read, “Explosives laboratory uncovered in Nablus.” There followed a list of
the items uncovered in the laboratory. The Jerusalem Post’s article by
Yaakov Katz was captioned, “IDF uncovers deadly stuffed animals in a raid
on Nablus bomb factory.” Stuffed animals used to camouflage bombs?
Children’s playthings literally transformed into the means of causing
mayhem, death and destruction? Why are there no “one picture is worth a
thousand words” photos??? Why wasn’t there a Press tour of the factory
before it was destroyed? Why was this opportunity, to show the terrorists as
they really are, thrown-away? Forget about maximizing, the failure to simply
utilize this opportunity goes well beyond demonstrating a lack of ability to
conceptualize. It comes close enough that a courts-Martial should decide if
it is dereliction of duty.
This is not the time to
mince words. The media war is ongoing. There is no print, no broadcast
ceasefire. We are loosing and loosing badly. The very existence of the State
is jeopardized. What we have been doing is killing us. My proof is in the
print and broadcast media every day. We must change our tactics. It is the
only way to avoid the next loss. It could be forever. |